| It is mentioned in a tradition that 'Adi b | The same rule applies with regard to shooting arrows in hunting |
|---|---|
| The Qur'an's response to this question seems to be aimed, in the first place, at the reform of this mentality | This is the view of Malik |
There is some disagreement among the jurists as to the hunting animals whose catch is lawful.
29| Jika buruan itu dimakannya, berarti tidak ditangkapnya untuk tuannya, maka tidak halal dimakan sebagaimana tercantum dalam kedua hadis sahih Bukhari dan Muslim | 中国语文 - Ma Jian : 他们问你准许他们吃什么，你说：准许你们吃－切佳美的食物，你们曾遵真主的教诲，而加以训练的鹰犬等所为你们捕获的动物，也是可以吃的；你们放纵鹰犬的时候，当诵真主之名，并当敬畏真主。 A third group of jurists is of the opinion that if the hunting animal which has eaten part of the game is a beast it becomes prohibited, but not so if the hunting animal is a bird |
|---|---|
| Sekurang-kurangnya untuk mengetahui hal itu dibutuhkan pengamatan sebanyak tiga kali | This is the opinion of Abu Hanifah and his disciples |
Berbeda halnya dengan yang tidak terlatih, maka tangkapannya itu tidak halal.
| There is a certain subtlety in how the query is answered | This is the doctrine of Shafi'i |
|---|---|
| Some jurists are of the opinion that if the hunting animal, whether bird or beast, eats any part of the game, it becomes prohibited since the act of eating signifies that the animal hunted for its own sake rather than for the sake of its master | Sebagai ciri-cirinya bila dilepas ia berangkat dan bila dicegah ia berhenti serta ditahannya buruan itu dan tidak dimakannya |
This means a complete reversal of the old religious outlook according to which everything that has not been declared lawful is considered prohibited.